What Evidence Do You Need to Prove a Premises Liability Claim in Washington?
Every year, more than one million Americans are injured in slip and fall or trip and fall accidents or by falling merchandise. Some of these accidents happen because of clumsiness, but many are caused by hazards like slippery floors, icy surfaces, and other unsafe conditions the owner should have corrected. When an accident on someone else’s property causes injuries, the injured person might be entitled to compensation. But to prove a premises liability claim in Washington, you must gather evidence to establish the four elements of a negligence claim: duty, breach, causation, and damages. Understanding these four elements and the evidence you need to prove them is the first step toward recovering the compensation you deserve.
Key Takeaways
- When an accident on someone else’s property causes injuries, the scope of the owner’s duty is determined by why the visitor was on the premises: whether they were an invitee, a licensee, or a trespasser.
- Traditionally, proving a premises liability claim required proof that the owner had actual or constructive notice of a hazard.
- Washington law recognizes an important exception to the notice requirement when a business owner’s methods of operation are such that the existence of a hazardous condition is reasonably foreseeable.
- Most premises liability claims in Washington must be filed within three years. Washington’s pure comparative negligence rule applies and a person who was partially at fault can still recover compensation.
What You Must Prove in a Washington Premises Liability Case
To prove a premises liability claim in Washington, the injured person must establish all four elements of negligence by a preponderance of the evidence, meaning it is more likely than not that the accident occurred the way the injured person claims.
The four elements of any personal injury claim are duty, breach, causation, and damages. However, premises liability claims are unique in that a property owner’s duty depends on the legal status of the injured person, which is determined by why they were on the premises. Under Tincani v. Inland Empire Zoological Soc., 124 Wn.2d 121, 875 P.2d 621 (1994), the scope of a property owner’s duty is determined by why a visitor was on the property:
- Invitees are owed the highest duty of care. They are on the property at the express or implied invitation of the owner. Property owners must protect their safety by inspecting the premises for dangerous conditions, fixing or warning about them, and maintaining the premises in a reasonably safe condition.
- Licensees are on the property with the express or implied permission of the property owner, but are there for a non-business purpose. Property owners must warn of hazards a guest would be unlikely to discover on their own, but do not have a duty to inspect the property for potential hazards.
- Trespassers have no right to be on the property and are owed the lowest duty. The property owner must not willfully or recklessly injure them. Exceptions may apply if the injured trespasser is a child.
Once the property owner’s duty has been established, the injured person must show how the property owner breached their duty, that their injuries were caused by the property owner’s breach of duty and are a type of harm a reasonable person would ordinarily foresee, and their measurable losses, like medical bills, lost income, and pain and suffering.
How to Prove the Property Owner Knew or Should Have Known
Traditionally, to prove a premises liability claim in Washington, the injured person needed to demonstrate that the property owner knew or should have known of the hazard but failed to address it. They could show the property owner had actual notice of the hazard, meaning they knew about the hazard that caused the injury. This might be an employee who saw a spill on the floor, a customer report about a broken handrail, or a property manager who saw a leaky pipe.
An injured person could also show constructive notice, which means the property owner should have known about the hazard because a reasonably careful owner would have discovered it. An injured person might establish constructive notice through testimony from an employee about the owner’s cleaning or inspection schedule and whether it was followed.
How the Foreseeability Exception Can Remove the Notice Requirement
Washington law recognizes an important exception to the notice requirement. Under Pimentel v. Roundup Co., 100 Wn.2d 39, 666 P.2d 888 (1983), “notice need not be shown…when the nature of the proprietor's business and his methods of operation are such that the existence of unsafe conditions on the premises is reasonably foreseeable.”
In Pimentel, a woman and her husband were shopping inside a store and stopped to look at a magazine rack containing home improvement books. While standing in front of the magazine rack, the woman was struck on the foot by a can of paint, which had been placed there by an employee earlier that day and apparently had fallen from a shelf beneath the magazine rack. The Supreme Court of Washington ruled that, when a business owner’s method of operation involves the reasonable probability that certain risks will occur, those risks are foreseeable and the injured person does not need to prove the owner had actual or constructive notice of the hazard that caused the injury. Instead, the jury must determine whether the property owner had taken all reasonable precautions to protect invitees from foreseeable risks. However, the Court limited the exception, noting that “the requirement of showing notice will be eliminated only if the particular self-service operation of the defendant is shown to be such that the existence of unsafe conditions is reasonably foreseeable.”
For years, Pimentel had only applied to self-service businesses. But in Johnson v. Liquor & Cannabis Board, 197 Wn.2d 605, 486 P.3d 125 (2021), the Supreme Court of Washington expanded the foreseeability exception “into a general rule that an invitee may prove notice with evidence that the ‘nature of the proprietor’s business and his methods of operation are such that the existence of unsafe conditions on the premises is reasonably foreseeable.’” Under Johnson, if the proprietor’s methods of operation make a particular hazard reasonably likely to occur, the injured person does not need to prove the owner had notice of the specific hazard.
Types of Evidence That Strengthen a Premises Liability Claim
Despite the foreseeability exception to the notice requirement, an injured person still must establish the elements of negligence to prove their case. Evidence commonly used to prove a premises liability claim in Washington includes:
- Photos and video of the hazard. Photos and video of the hazardous condition show what it looked like on the day of the incident, before the property owner had a chance to clean it up or fix it.
- Incident or accident reports. When an injury occurs in a place of business, the business owner typically completes an incident or accident report. These reports are made soon after the accident occurred, before witnesses’ memories fade or the property owner changes their account of what happened.
- Surveillance footage. Most businesses have surveillance footage of their property. This evidence can help prove how long the hazard existed and that employees were or should have been aware of it.
- Maintenance and inspection logs. Most businesses keep a schedule of when inspections and cleanings are supposed to occur and whether they happened. This information can show whether the owner conducted regular inspections and cleanings and can help establish that the owner knew or should have known about and addressed the hazard.
- Witness statements. Statements from employees or other customers who saw the incident can corroborate how it happened.
- Complaints about prior similar incidents. Complaints about similar incidents can show that the accident was foreseeable.
- Medical records. The injured person’s medical records establish the nature and extent of their injuries, when they received medical care and treatment, and the extent of the medical bills and other losses.
Each of these types of evidence helps build a case and establish the four elements required to prove the owner was negligent.
How to Preserve Evidence Right After an Injury
When an accident on someone else’s property causes injuries, the steps you take in the hours and days afterward can shape your claim and affect your chances of success. Requesting and preserving evidence will give you the information you need to prove all four elements of negligence.
The following are several steps you can take to build a strong claim:
- If you are able, take pictures and video of the hazard before it is fixed or removed. Include wide shots that show the hazard and the surrounding area, as well as close-ups of the hazard itself.
- Request a copy of the incident or accident report. Note the date and time of the accident and, at a minimum, ask for the names of any employees who assisted you.
- If there were any witnesses, ask them for their name and phone number or email address.
- Request, in writing, that the owner preserve any video or surveillance footage. These records are routinely destroyed under a business’s records retention policy, and a written request puts them on notice that they need to preserve the information. The owner could face legal sanctions if they destroy this evidence.
- Promptly seek medical attention. See a doctor or other medical provider as quickly as possible, even if you believe your injuries are minor. Many people initially feel fine, only to have their symptoms worsen in the hours or days after an injury. Medical treatment also creates a record of your injuries and the care and treatment you needed. A medical record also helps prove your injuries were caused by the accident rather than something else.
Contact a Personal Injury Lawyer
When falling merchandise or a fall on someone else’s property causes serious injuries, you must act quickly to preserve and gather the evidence you need to prove your claim. An attorney can help prove a premises liability claim in Washington and achieve a favorable outcome.
Attorney Brett B. Herron has unparalleled experience handling complex premises liability cases and has brought lawsuits against many corporate retail stores in connection with dangerous conditions that have caused clients to suffer personal injury. He has represented clients in claims against The Home Depot, Lowe’s, Macy’s, Safeway, Fred Meyer, and commercial property management companies.
With locations in Burien and Bellevue, Herron Law Office, PLLC, helps people throughout Washington who were injured because of hazardous conditions on someone else’s property. We welcome you to contact us for a consultation to discuss your case by calling 425-451-9110.
